When Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl launched on the Swap in October 2021, the comparisons to a sure Nintendo platform fighter have been pure and inevitable. Heck, we spent our overview attempting — and admittedly failing — to keep away from the plain similarity to Tremendous Smash Bros. Final. Certainly, when a sport comes out that brings characters from a number of franchises collectively to combat on a platform-based area and knock opponents out of the boundaries, it is virtually begging for sure comparisons to be made. In spite of everything, Tremendous Smash Bros. basically birthed the sub-genre.
It appears one dev is not too happy with a specific comparability, and we will perceive why. Because the starting each enthusiastic followers and detractors have been cavalier with their hyperbole, and in a brief Twitter thread, All-Star Brawl character designer and programmer Thaddeus Crews acknowledged that he’d slightly folks not use the time period “Smash-killer” anymore, saying that the comparability has a confirmed observe document of instigating battle.
In a separate submit, Thaddeus quoted YouTuber ‘IntroSpective’, who acknowledged that jokes made towards All-Star Brawl on his channel will finish after the creators received in contact. Thaddeus clarified that the interplay between the 2 held no animosity:
We’ve got to say, we get it. We have watched the video in query, and whereas IntroSpective’s comparability is seemingly meant to not be taken severely, its clearly meant as a slight on Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl. The Nickelodeon sport is a really stable piece of labor however a lot, a lot smaller in scale to Nintendo’s behemoth by way of developer assets. For the devs who work exhausting to deliver such a sport to life, we perceive why the fixed comparisons — lighthearted or in any other case — may show a problem.
What do you make of Thaddeus’s feedback on Twitter? Do you agree together with his assertion, otherwise you do assume any comparability between the 2 IP is related? Tell us within the feedback beneath.